Maud (Part III) - Alfred, Lord Tennyson
A Final Reckoning Through War and Inner Awakening
[Excerpt from Part III]
See what a lovely shell,
Small and pure as a pearl,
Lying close to my foot!
Frail, but a work divine,
Made so fairly well
With delicate spire and whorl,
Where can be found hardly a flaw or a stain?
Surely this world is not all blind; there is more than the eye,
Something behind the veil so sweetly wrought,
Though dark the ways that lead us to its gate.
War! is it war again?
Is it peace or war? Civil war, as I think, and that of a kind
The viler, as underhand, not openly bearing the sword.
(… later lines …)
Let it flame or fade, and the war-roll thunder and roll
In the narrow cannon-throat of the war,
But I count it best to fight again, to strike at the lies that kill,
To follow the watchword sound, for the truth must war with ill,
And the God of love give victory still!
[Public Domain: Excerpted for brevity from “Maud” (Part III) by Alfred, Lord Tennyson. Lines may vary slightly by edition.]
In Part III of Alfred, Lord Tennyson’s dramatic poem “Maud,” the speaker reaches a moment of profound reckoning. The earlier sections showed him descending into grief, guilt, and near-madness following the fatal duel that claimed Maud’s brother. Here, in the final portion, he attempts to transcend these internal torments by embracing the larger conflict of war. Blending stark reflections on personal anguish with a newfound sense of purpose, Tennyson presents the speaker as one who seeks moral or spiritual redemption by confronting broader social and political ills.
The excerpt opens with an image of a beautiful seashell, a small work of nature that prompts the speaker to ponder whether something beyond the surface—"behind the veil"—reveals a hidden design or deeper significance. This glimmer of hope stands in contrast to the "dark ways" that previously dominated his life. For the first time, the speaker suggests a possibility of light or truth existing within a seemingly chaotic world.
Tennyson then shifts from this quietly contemplative moment into references to "War! is it war again?"—signaling that the speaker sees external conflict as a path out of his obsessive grief and guilt. However, the poem does not simply glorify war. Instead, the speaker references "civil war" and underhanded forms of strife, insinuating that such battles might well be moral or personal rather than purely military. Tennyson’s language hints at the hypocrisy, dishonesty, or inner wars that plague his era, reinforcing how the speaker’s personal crisis converges with a society in turmoil.
In the final lines, the speaker expresses a resolve to "fight again"—not only in a literal sense but also in a metaphorical battle against falsehoods and destructive impulses. This gesture echoes the Victorian conception of war as a testing ground for duty and valor, yet Tennyson refrains from offering a simple patriotic sentiment. Instead, the speaker searches for cosmic justification, trusting "the God of love" to vindicate truth over "the lies that kill." This mingling of martial imagery with spiritual longing reflects Tennyson’s deeper commentary: that redemption may come from resisting cynicism and striving for a higher principle, even in a flawed world.
In total, Part III of "Maud" moves from quiet contemplation and glimpses of natural beauty to an impassioned call to arms, symbolizing the speaker’s last bid to regain a sense of identity and honor. The poem’s shifting meter and rapid changes of tone mirror the speaker’s unsettled mind, culminating in a precarious balance between despair and defiance, guilt and resolve. Through this final act, Tennyson challenges the reader to see how personal torment and broader social conflict can intertwine, leaving open the question of whether the speaker’s newfound determination truly leads to redemption—or represents yet another escape from his internal anguish.
Key points
• Shows the speaker’s transition from despair to a form of committed engagement—possibly war.
• Contrasts delicate, hopeful imagery (a pristine shell) with the looming specter of conflict.
• Suggests that the speaker’s turmoil resonates with larger societal battles, both moral and literal.
• Highlights Tennyson’s theme of seeking redemption through action and confrontation of untruths.
• Concludes the poem’s arc of obsession, guilt, and self-discovery in a moment of ambiguous resolve.